Lectio divina
  • Blog
  • About
  • Contact

Lectio divina

Thoughts on following Jesus in today's world

Follow

Day 1. Hermeneutically speaking

3/22/2014

18 Comments

 

We’ve all been there; sitting in class watching some kid annoy another student and the moment they respond the teacher turns around, interpreting the reaction as the provocation. If the teacher fails to get to the bottom of the story and interpret it correctly, things can turn out badly for the one who reacted, while the instigator gets away with it.

Science and Art

And so we come to the Bible. Exegesis and Hermeneutics. These terms sound like they were invented by Seminary professors in an attempt to protect their jobs by throwing off the un-initiated, but they are really easy to understand. One (exegesis) is simply the science of figuring out what is being said, often by whom and when, the other (hermeneutics) is the art of understanding the meaning of what was said and it’s application.

Today there is an enormous debate raging between what the Bible says and what it means. This has always been so of course from the earliest days.

The reality is that facts don’t change but meaning does. One is a science and the other is an art. Fortunately the Good Book itself is amply furnished with examples that can help us balance these two components. Lets look at a couple of them.

In John 7:53-8:11 we read the story of the woman taken in adultery. In this emotionally charged account, the scribes and Pharisees demand of Jesus: “Now in the law, Moses commanded us to stone such women. Now what do you say?” What Jesus said is well know: “Let anyone among you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone at her.”

According to the Bible, (Leviticus 20:10 and Deuteronomy 22:222) the Scribes and Pharisees were correct, that is what it said. So why was there even any debate?

In another instance Jesus is walking through the fields one day with his disciples and they glean some corn to eat as they pass though. The law allowed you to snack on a neighbors crops in this way, as long as you didn't bag any of it up for later, it was like the first "all you can eat" buffet idea. However in this instance there was a problem, it was the Sabbath day and no work was to be done on the Sabbath. The kind of work that was forbidden specifically included creative or commercial work such as gleaning, and the penalty for transgression was death. Check out Exodus 31:14: "Therefore you are to observe the sabbath, for it is holy to you. Everyone who profanes it shall surely be put to death; for whoever does any work on it, that person shall be cut off from among his people.…". So once again, the Pharisee's exegesis was correct, what Jesus and the disciples were doing was a clear violation of the law. Jesus however responds to them with a surprising statement: "If you had known what these words mean, ‘I desire mercy, not sacrifice,’    you would not have condemned the innocent." (Matthew 12:7 NIV)

So then who is right? And why? To unpack this a little we have to look at what Jesus said in Matthew 12:7: "If you had known what these words mean". He affirmed their 'scientific' understanding of the law and what it said, but berated them for their failure to artfully see the bigger picture, the meaning behind the words.

He pointed to the law of God's Desire upon which the law of Moses was constructed. The law to which Moses was and will always be subject.

This was the genius of Christ. He took every jot and tittle of the Mosaic Law and drew out the meaning, freeing it from itself and re-imaging it through the eyes of love, and mercy. He turned it around from something that we served to something that serves us. From a law we had to keep to a law that keeps us.

Was then Jesus pleased with the woman taken in adultery? Was he blessing her failure. No. But by showing the law that appeared to condemn her was actually the law that cared for her, he unleashed the mercy, the optimism, and the love that could now power her recovery.

The reason for the failure of the scribes and Pharisees to get it right stemmed from their motive. They were economically and socially committed to supporting the law. If Jesus were to show a better way of interpreting the law then they would need to change or go out of business.

They were thinking about themselves and about preserving their way of life. The woman was expendable. Jesus thought about the person of the woman and about her restoration, while modeling a new way of approaching the law to the leaders. He was all about a better tomorrow, they were all about the status quo, no matter how it was failing the people.

You've got to love Jesus for that! But you know, when you look down through history you see this kind of thing happening all the time. It seems we are predisposed to sticking to our exegesis of the text, because interpretation is so much more messy.

Seeking to grow in wisdom and understanding, working beyond what the Bible said yesterday to what it means today can sound a bit like the road less traveled, but if you are bold enough to take that road, it will surely lead to more justice, inclusion, mercy and love for all of us, inside or outside of the classroom.

18 Comments
Zoran
3/21/2014 01:40:22 pm

Reply
Simon Bull link
3/21/2014 02:42:36 pm

Thanks Zoran, if you had a problem posting your comment, feel free to try agin!

Reply
Simon Bull
3/21/2014 10:36:55 pm

Why was the law given in the first place if people could so easily escape it's consequences?

When we raise children, we lay down the law and guide them. We expect them to experiment a little and deviate from the path, but when they do we take away their toys or their cell phones or, as they did when I was a child, give a sharp clip around the ear, or worse. The point though was to direct them into being productive adults who would make their own positive mark on the world. So our punishments were motivated towards a better tomorrow. We do not wait for our children to transgress so we can destroy them.

And so it is with the Law of Moses. It was given for life, not for death.

Reply
Jim Staples
3/21/2014 01:52:30 pm

"He turned it around from something that we served to something that serves us"

The transforming grace of Jesus so beautifully stated. Thanks for sharing.

Reply
Simon Bull link
3/21/2014 02:41:32 pm

Thanks for the encouraging words Jim!

Reply
Annie Post Nystrom
3/21/2014 02:37:28 pm

Love the grace and love. Nice to be friends with someone who thinks like me. Sorry..but it's much easier.

Reply
Simon Bull
3/21/2014 02:43:04 pm

Thanks Annie!

Reply
Mildred V. De Vera link
3/21/2014 03:04:02 pm

What an inspirational insight about Jesus and his teachings as it is applied in our world today. I am in awe and reverence with your knowledge on Religion and your exceptional talent/gift of Art, Simon. I have learned a lot from your composition, Hermeneutically Speaking that I have not learned from my own religion. Your devotional journey is in a timely manner with Lent. I want to follow your devotional journey and learn more about the heart and mind of Christ. May it serve as a guide to enlighten my heart and mind to understand the deeper meaning of the teachings of Christ as it applies in my life and in our lives.

Reply
Simon Bull
3/21/2014 03:05:19 pm

Thank you Mildred. Let's walk the road together.

Reply
Sally Newbery
3/21/2014 05:51:22 pm

Really helpful & inspiring, Simon. I'd love to hear more.

Reply
Chris Price link
3/21/2014 07:37:23 pm

Thanks for sharing but I think I see it differently. In the case of the woman caught in adultery Jesus didn't take a different line he actually took the Pharisees position to its logical conclusion. According to the Law the first person to cast a stone should have been the person who witnessed the transgression (a tricky one). Jesus exposed them, not as being self-interested but, as having double standards. Ironically this story was considered uninspired for some time because the church thought Jesus would and should have condemned her. The Pharisees' Sabbath laws went way beyond what was in the Torah. Jesus accused them of obeying laws made by men and ignoring God's laws.

The fundamental difference between Jesus and the Pharisees was more that they would pick and choose what suited them while Jesus came to fulfil the Law and make it more perfect. If he had broken any of the laws he could not be sacrificed as an unblemished lamb and we would remain slaves to the Law just as the Pharisees were.

Jesus said of the Pharisees that they stood at the gate [of the Law] and prevented others from understanding yet went to the ends of the earth to make converts more sons of hell than they were.

Reply
Catherine
3/21/2014 09:05:57 pm

Reply
Simon Bull
3/21/2014 09:46:50 pm

Great to hear from you Chris!

Reply
Simon Bull
3/21/2014 10:38:42 pm

Great question


When we raise children, we lay down the law and guide them. We expect them to experiment a little and deviate from the path, but when they do we take away their toys or their cell phones or, as they did when I was a child, give a sharp clip around the ear, or worse. The point though was to direct them into being productive adults who would make their own positive mark on the world. So our punishments were motivated towards a better tomorrow. We do not wait for our children to transgress so we can destroy them.

And so it is with the Law of Moses. It was given for life, not for death

Reply
Shirley
3/21/2014 10:47:13 pm

The thing I like most about this, in addition to being well written and simple to follow, is that it prompted me to pull my Bible out and start searching.

Reply
Laurie Schulz
3/22/2014 12:57:33 am

Hi Simon. I enjoyed this devotion--so you have the gift of teaching too? Eventually u could compile a book! Keep them coming.

Reply
Mildred De Vera link
3/22/2014 09:44:15 am

In every family, parents establish rules that the children have to abide by. They are guidelines to help the children understand what is acceptable and what is not. When children disobey and/or break rules, a corresponding punishment and/or some privileges are taken away from then to teach them a lesson. As parents, we prepare our children to grow up to be responsible and honorable adults in society.

Rules are part of everyday human life. We find them in our homes, in schools, the work place, and in general society. In any type of society, there has to be some guidelines that dictate how people act towards each other. Without rules, the world would be chaotic!

Life can not be organized without rules. If there are no rules, everyone is free to do whatever they want, most people will behave selfishly, and life will be unfair. We need rules to help us get along together and show respect to each other. They are designed to ensure fairness, safety, and respect for other people's rights. We follow rules and laws to make the world peaceful and fair.

Reply
Simon Bull
3/22/2014 10:53:09 am

This is a great contribution. Thank you Mildred.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Picture

    Lectio Divina

    A devotional journey with artist Simon Bull.

    Archives

    October 2014
    July 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014

    Enter your email address:

    Delivered by FeedBurner

    RSS Feed


Proudly powered by Weebly